Socrates on Communism & Capitalism
WHAT, THEN, IS THE DIFFERENCE?
Felicia Flake: Oh, Socrates, I’m so glad to find you here today.
Socrates: When we first met, you were not nearly so eager, remember?
F: That’s because I’m off drugs now and into something really meaningful. And that’s what I want to talk to you about today. I want you to meet my new friend Karl. He’s going to meet me here in a few minutes. He’s a terribly important person to me because he’s given me a great gift: a cause to live and work for. I was drugging because I was drifting; now I know I’ve got direction.
S: If he has truly given you a cause to live for, that is a great gift indeed, especially in this age of a plethora of means and a dearth of ends. I hope his gift is a true one and not just an apparent one.
F: That’s why I’m so glad you’re here today, Socrates. I can’t wait to hear you two in dialogue. I couldn’t stand up to your cross-examinations, but I’m sure Karl can. Perhaps you can even learn something from him.
S: I can learn something from everyone.
F: Perhaps he can even give you the gift he gave me.
S: Perhaps. But I am not drifting. I have a cause to give my life for.
F: Your questioning? How can it be your end and purpose in life if you never come to an end of it? Do you just seek for the sake of seeking?
S: An excellent question, Felicia; in fact, the best one you have yet asked!
F: And do you have an excellent answer?
S: Ah, my good infection seems to be spreading, I see. Good, good! The student begins to outdo her teacher. And thus the teacher’s purpose is fulfilled.
F: You still haven’t answered my question.
You May Also Enjoy
Vertical religion and horizontal religion are parts of an integral whole. You go up by going sideways, and you go best sideways by focusing upward.
An example of a powerful ruler who should be like a caring elder but seems more bent on crushing dissent comes from an unexpected source.
Socrates would say that good music is music that makes the soul better, that is, more harmonious, and bad music is music that makes the soul unharmonious.