The Narthex
Accompaniment and Discernment
Certain words, including some suspiciously 'churchy' ones, are enlisted in all manner of nonsense
By James Hanink | March 24th 2023 11:12 AMWords mean something. Sadly, their overuse leaves them captive to clichés. Thus captive, they can be enlisted in all manner of nonsense. Two examples come to mind: accompaniment and discernment. Note that both of them have become suspiciously “churchy.” Let’s start with accompaniment. Rightly used, it means “being with” another…
READ FULL BLOG POSTKnowing the Future
Metaphysics takes us beyond empirical puzzles and bumps up against mystery
By James Hanink | March 6th 2023 9:40 PMLife is a mystery to live, not a problem to solve. And metaphysics is rich in mystery! Here’s a contrast. Science often advances by resolution and replacement. For example, Galileo resolves Ptolemy’s puzzles, and heliocentrism emerges. Einstein resolves Newton’s puzzles, and the theory of relativity replaces classical physics. Closer to…
READ FULL BLOG POSTThe Point of Politics
Politics is about advancing the common good and serving all the people
By James Hanink | February 22nd 2023 6:34 PMGood politics calls for building bridges and forming coalitions. The American Solidarity Party gets it. Here in California, as elsewhere, the powerbrokers, whether Democrat or Republican, have a vested interest in blocking new parties from getting ballot access. The “duopoly” has an effective strategy for shoring up the status quo.…
READ FULL BLOG POSTInterview with The Grim Reaper
The hands of the atomic scientists' Doomsday Clock now stand at 90 seconds to midnight
By James Hanink | February 8th 2023 12:19 PMA new cartoon, courtesy of Harry Bliss, shows a fellow chatting with The Grim Reaper. The Reaper, sensitive to the chap’s feelings, tells him not to worry overmuch -- it’s just a preliminary interview. But should we believe Mr. Reaper? Or should we be worried, very worried? The latest report…
READ FULL BLOG POSTVerbal Violence
The self-reference pronoun 'they' implies lost self-unity & 'it' declares self-objectification
By James Hanink | January 23rd 2023 10:32 PMA Civil Rights activist turned thug named H. Rap Brown was right. “Violence,” he said, “is as American as cherry pie.” Violence is also pluriform, and it includes the violence we do to language when we turn that violence on ourselves. Here’s an example. Last week in Atlanta police shot…
READ FULL BLOG POSTDoubts About Definitions
Do we need to define religion, and can we?
By James Hanink | January 6th 2023 10:15 PMA friend just authored an important paper on why religious freedom is a human right. I agree that it is, and I applaud the range and rigor of his analysis. He’ll catch a lot of flak, though. Not everyone thinks that religion is for the good, much less that it…
READ FULL BLOG POSTWhat Is a Number?
It's not easy to say whether numbers were invented, discovered, or generated
By James Hanink | December 30th 2022 1:38 PMFelix, my youngest grandson, has aged out of Sesame Street. Since leaving, though, he calls himself “The Count.” Of late he’s busy counting his Legos. Trump, keen to remain POTUS, wanted more votes to count. No luck. Of late he’s counting the legal actions he faces. For better or worse,…
READ FULL BLOG POSTCrisis Pregnancy Centers and Cognitive Dissonance
Muddled thinking leads to simultaneous targeting of and awarding CPCs for their service
By James Hanink | December 13th 2022 10:19 PMLast month the L.A. Times ran a piece titled "New law targets crisis pregnancy centers in L.A." (Nov. 3, B3). It served up a noxious mix: a bloated press release for Mike Feuer, the city attorney, and more lousy journalism from the Times. To wit: the writers don't bother to cite any crisis…
READ FULL BLOG POSTWork, Workers & Wonder
Secular man won’t discuss -- but desperately needs -- a theology of work
By James Hanink | November 29th 2022 8:37 PMUnder the direction of the United Auto Workers, 48,000 “academic workers,” chiefly researchers and graduate students, at the University of California are on strike—the largest such job action in history. It even includes the Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory, whose task is to “mind” and “develop” the country’s nuclear arsenal. The…
READ FULL BLOG POSTMeme Mischief
Such 'thought-blockers' can be surprisingly hard to resist
By James Hanink | November 17th 2022 3:12 PMMake way for the memes! How many have you seen today? In an election season, they’re more plentiful than autumn leaves. Just what are they and where are they from? Are they friend or foe? Broadly considered, a meme is an idea or behavior that is widely imitated; it spreads…
READ FULL BLOG POSTA Perilous ‘Compromise’
An attempt to find middle ground on abortion fails for several reasons
By James Hanink | October 31st 2022 8:07 PMRoberto Dell’Oro, a Californian bioethicist at Loyola Marymount University, recently proposed a compromise on abortion law. Since he is a member of the Pontifical Academy for Life, his proposal is attracting wide interest in Catholic circles. Dell’Oro is no friend of the Supreme Court’s recent Dobbs decision. He chiefly objects…
READ FULL BLOG POSTOn California’s Prop 1
An open letter to a public servant regarding a grave injustice
By James Hanink | October 10th 2022 8:31 PMPeople matter first, and that’s always and everywhere true. So I begin with a thumbnail sketch of my neighbor, Alex Padilla. He’s an affable fellow. Gregarious. Even avuncular. Alex is a family man with three adult children. Padilla also holds a key post as a Special Investigator with the Los…
READ FULL BLOG POSTTruth and Consequences
Honest dialogue and, indeed, human communication depend on objective truth
By James Hanink | September 26th 2022 2:51 PMI like “Ike,” as I’ll call him. He was a catalyst for the pre-synod “listening session” that my seminary friends of yesteryear recently held. For my part I only “listened in” on the session. Then I offered a critique here, in a blog post. Ike didn’t much like what he…
READ FULL BLOG POSTMini-Synod with Old Friends
Our group was asked 'How has the Church helped you' and 'hurt you?'
By James Hanink | September 12th 2022 9:13 PMA read of the German synod documents reminds me that revisionists are keener on erasing than on building. But no one invited me. I did get invited to a mini-synod session by classmates from the minor seminary that I attended for six years. What led to the mini-synod was an…
READ FULL BLOG POST'Lifestyle' Lament
The interplay between the person and community is not a style. It is, rather, the human way of life
By James Hanink | August 30th 2022 9:43 PMWho me? Lament my lifestyle? No, I don’t even know what it is. But I do lament and bemoan the overuse of the word lifestyle. That is, if it has any worthy use at all. Why do I take umbrage? Of course, there’s a place for style. I wish there…
READ FULL BLOG POST