The Narthex
JPII's 'Game Changer'
Does Theology of the Body develop the moral doctrine of Humanae Vitae?
By James Thunder | September 28th 2021 5:55 PMReview of: Mere Marriage: Sexual Difference and Christian Doctrine. By Andrew D. Cannon, Ph.D. Alphonsus Publishing, available at MereMarriage.com. 215 pages. $24.95. George Weigel devoted eleven pages of his 1999 biography of Pope John Paul II, Witness to Hope, to the saint-pope’s Theology of the Body. He concluded that…
READ FULL BLOG POSTOn Liturgical Change
The Communion fast and the 'smells and bells' of Mass -- Part 7
By James Thunder | June 1st 2021 2:16 PMEveryone -- whether priest, bishop, or layperson -- has ideas on how to change the liturgy. If I had my druthers, I would make the following changes, but these changes are neither mine to make nor a priest's to make: the congregation would kneel for the penitential moments of the…
READ FULL BLOG POSTMass Facing the People or the Altar
A look at liturgical changes in the Mass after Vatican II - Part 6
By James Thunder | May 25th 2021 5:18 PMThe post-conciliar period saw liturgical abuses. One alleged abuse is moving altars away from the back walls of churches to allow, or require, the celebrant to face the people. Let us look at Cardinal Ratzinger’s 2003 foreword to U.M. Lang's Turning Towards the Lord: Orientation in Liturgical Prayer (2d ed.…
READ FULL BLOG POSTPaul VI's Mass Revisions
A look at liturgical changes in the Mass after Vatican II - Part 5
By James Thunder | May 24th 2021 1:53 PMThe Novus Ordo brought a number of reforms besides celebrating in the vernacular. In his Apostolic Constitution of 1969, Pope St. Paul VI approvingly referred to Pius XII’s restoration in 1951 and 1955 of the Easter Vigil and the Rite of Holy Week, respectively. He also cited the desire of…
READ FULL BLOG POSTOld Rite, New Rite
A look at liturgical changes in the Mass after Vatican II -- Part 4
By James Thunder | May 17th 2021 2:32 PMCardinal Ratzinger, the future Pope Benedict XVI, wrote in the Foreword to U.M. Lang's Turning Towards the Lord: Orientation in Liturgical Prayer that the Vatican Council did not require the “disappearance of Latin.” In support of this statement, the cardinal quoted Section 1 of Paragraph 36 of the Constitution on…
READ FULL BLOG POSTJohn Paul II's View on the Vernacular
A look at liturgical changes in the Mass after Vatican II -- Part 3
By James Thunder | May 10th 2021 2:42 PMI begin this installment by stating my love for the Latin language. I studied it in high school and graduate school. I drew on my knowledge of the language to write my master’s thesis, Aquinas on Marriage. I recently taught Latin for five years to grade schoolers on Saturday mornings.…
READ FULL BLOG POSTMass in English Spread Like Wildfire
A look at liturgical changes in the Mass after Vatican II - Part 2
By James Thunder | May 3rd 2021 2:02 PMThe first Mass in English in the United States was celebrated on August 24, 1964, by Father Frederick R. McManus in St. Louis. A New York Times article, “Catholics Hear Mass in English Today for First Time in the U.S.” (Aug. 24, 1964), describes the translation as “hurried”; I am perplexed…
READ FULL BLOG POSTMass in the Vernacular
A look at certain liturgical changes in the Mass after Vatican II -- Part 1
By James Thunder | April 26th 2021 12:31 PMThis new blog series addresses certain liturgical changes in the Latin Rite Mass, from the vantage point of a half century after Vatican II. These changes notably began with Mass in the vernacular languages rather than solely in Latin. I begin by observing that I know of two instances in…
READ FULL BLOG POSTHoliness in Relationships - Part XXXV
Many saints had deep relationships with their contemporaries who were also saints
By James Thunder | April 14th 2021 3:14 PMTypically our statues and paintings portray saints as individuals. And except for martyrs who are often canonized in groups, canonizations are of individual saints. Nonetheless, many non-martyred canonized saints have had deep relationships with their contemporaries who were also saints. A few are: Mary and Joseph; Sarah and Tobias; Ruth…
READ FULL BLOG POSTRecent Decrees on Holiness - Part XXXIV
Ten more laypersons have been subjects of papal decrees on miracles & heroic virtue
By James Thunder | April 8th 2021 1:07 PMOver twenty blog posts ago I noted that during the 40 years from 1978 to 2018, 1,419 individuals were canonized and 1,249 of these were martyrs. Of the remainder, about 15-20 were laypersons -- some of which are special cases: those to whom Our Lady appeared, two who took vows…
READ FULL BLOG POSTArtists & Medical Personnel - Part XXXIII
French artist James Tissot returned to the Faith and illustrated a 'Life of Our Lord'
By James Thunder | March 30th 2021 12:20 PMIn order to learn how to recognize holiness in laypersons, we have looked at people by occupation. Let's finish with a few more: Artists Do you think any of the following Catholic artists were holy? Consider the painters Giotto (c. 1267-1337), Michelangelo (1475-1564), Raphael (1483-1520), Rubens (1577-1640), Jan van Eyck…
READ FULL BLOG POSTHoliness among Philanthropists - Part XXXII
Some donors live frugally and modestly, then make large donations upon their deaths
By James Thunder | March 23rd 2021 3:15 PMContinuing our discussion of recognizing lay holiness, let us look at philanthropists. We could discuss the donors of large sums -- $10 million, $100 million -- to causes consistent with Catholic social teaching, including Catholic schools, hospitals, and more. Many such donors take advantage of “naming rights” -- for buildings,…
READ FULL BLOG POSTWriters, Teachers, and Athletes - Part XXXI
Consider the possible holiness of Frank Sheed and Maisie Ward, G.K. Chesterton, Léon Bloy
By James Thunder | March 15th 2021 2:00 PMWould you say that any of the following Catholics, and their spouses, were holy? Writers The married couple Frank Sheed (1897-1982) and Maisie Ward (1889-1975) were writers and founders of a great Catholic publishing house, Sheed & Ward, in 1926. They had a son and a daughter. Other prominent lay…
READ FULL BLOG POSTStriving for Holiness at Work - Part XXX
A look at examples of lived faith in entertainers, musicians, lawyers, and businessmen
By James Thunder | March 8th 2021 4:52 PMHow does it look when men and women strive for holiness at work? Let's take examples from various occupations: Entertainers/TV-Film Personalities Among prominent Catholic entertainers is convert Alec Guinness (1914-2000). (See Guinness’s first of three autobiographies, Blessings in Disguise, from 1986.) See also his portrayal as G.K. Chesterton’s Father Brown…
READ FULL BLOG POSTLay Holiness - Part XXIX
Retail workers, architects, prisoners, scientists -- all can be holy
By James Thunder | March 1st 2021 2:51 PMWe continue to consider how holiness has been manifested in lay people of various occupations. Hospitality & Retail Workers At least two members of religious orders transformed the task of “doorkeeper” -- porter or meet-and-greeter -- to a holy life. One is Br. André Bessette, C.S.C. (1845-1937, canonized 2010), about…
READ FULL BLOG POST