The Narthex
A Plain Deflection
'Born this way' arguments push against free will and order
By Rob Agnelli (Archive) | April 15th 2019 4:24 PMIn his bid to become the first openly gay President of the United States, Pete Buttigieg recently went on the offensive against those people, especially Christians, who would object to his lifestyle. Rather than defending, he deflected, saying that their quarrel was not with him but “with my Creator.” Perhaps…
READ FULL BLOG POSTIn Defense of Anger
Have we lost the ability to truly love good and hate evil?
By Rob Agnelli (Archive) | April 8th 2019 3:03 PMIn what may be his most prophetic book, The Abolition of Man, C.S. Lewis examines the long-term effects on a culture that has swallowed the poison of moral subjectivism. Lewis envisions a future in which men have evolved to have no heart -- where, absent any objective values, the rule that…
READ FULL BLOG POSTGiving Vaccines a Shot
Behind 'public health' is the Catholic principle of the common good
By Rob Agnelli (Archive) | March 29th 2019 4:30 PMA suburban New York county has banned all unvaccinated minors from public places in hopes of staving off a recent measles outbreak in the area. This comes on the heels of a Northern Kentucky Health Department decision to ban unvaccinated students from school after a chickenpox outbreak there. Parents cite…
READ FULL BLOG POSTPuberty Blockers and the Principle of Totality
Man does not have unlimited license to mutilate his body
By Rob Agnelli (Archive) | March 18th 2019 3:20 PMThe Vatican News website recently printed an interview with a member of the Pontifical Academy for Life discussing the current standard of care for pubescent age children suffering from gender dysphoria. During the course of the questioning, the member, Dr. Laura Palazzani, said that in order to “accompany” children battling…
READ FULL BLOG POSTEven the Stoners Are Crying Out
Why is marijuana legalization a bad idea?
By Rob Agnelli (Archive) | March 8th 2019 5:26 PMWith presidential candidates bragging about it and state after state legalizing it, the use of recreational marijuana is fast becoming a cultural norm in our country. The Church, with only a few notable exceptions, has remained strangely silent on the issue, tacitly implying consent to the drug's “responsible use.” If…
READ FULL BLOG POSTNews Fit to Print?
What often passes as news is hardly earth shattering
By Rob Agnelli (Archive) | February 22nd 2019 3:23 PMWhen Alexis de Tocqueville visited America in the 1830s, one of the things he found remarkable was the incredibly high rate of literacy among the citizenry. But what was more remarkable to him was that, despite the high literacy rate, freedom of thought was practically non-existent. He blamed this on…
READ FULL BLOG POSTFending Off the Forces of Chaos
A true diabolic spirit denies the need for creeds and dogma
By Rob Agnelli (Archive) | February 14th 2019 3:24 PMFormer prefect of the Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith Gerhard Cardinal Müller issued a "Manifesto of Faith" last week. Many within the Church hailed the document as both necessary and timely. Others responded less positively, attacking his manifesto as animated by a spirit of division and comparing him…
READ FULL BLOG POSTThe Language of Agreement
Papering over differences serves not unity but confusion
By Rob Agnelli (Archive) | February 8th 2019 3:41 PMRecently someone asked me, “what would be the first thing you would do if you were suddenly elected Pope?” Although it was only a thought experiment, coming up with a single, first act was difficult. The weight of spiritually fathering billions of people must be both daunting and crushing. Ultimately…
READ FULL BLOG POSTRescuing Wonder
Seeing every created thing as a sign given to reveal God
By Rob Agnelli (Archive) | February 1st 2019 5:21 PMThe Protestant Revolution was not the only revolution of the 16th Century. Just three years prior to Luther’s presentation of his 95 Theses there was an even more earth shattering revolution started by Nicolas Copernicus. The Copernican revolution posited that the Earth was not the center of the cosmos but…
READ FULL BLOG POSTFacing Scandal Head On
Catholic prelates of our age could learn from Pope St. Gregory VII
By Rob Agnelli (Archive) | January 25th 2019 5:07 PMFor three days in the winter of 1077, King Henry IV of Germany knelt barefoot in the snow, clad in a coarse wool shirt, outside a castle gate in northern Italy. Inside the castle was Pope St. Gregory VII. The king desperately wanted the Pope to hear his confession and…
READ FULL BLOG POSTFruits of the Same Tree
One cannot be both pro-life and in favor of contraception
By Rob Agnelli (Archive) | January 18th 2019 4:03 PMSince its promulgation in 1995, St. John Paul II’s encyclical Evangelium Vitae has become like a pro-life manifesto. It is often cited not just for its eloquence but for its passionate defense of the great dignity of human life. The saintly pontiff is quick to point out not just the…
READ FULL BLOG POSTThe Rise of the Machines
Technology is good only insofar as it helps those who use it grow in virtue
By Rob Agnelli (Archive) | January 11th 2019 6:36 PMIn an interview for CBS’s 60 Minutes, one of the world’s leading experts on artificial intelligence, Kai Fu Lee, predicted that within 15 years robots and associated technologies will displace about 40% of the jobs in the world. We might quibble over the actual percentage or the rapidity at which…
READ FULL BLOG POSTKeeping the Holy Family Holy
To say that Mary was an unwed mother is no harmless fiction
By Rob Agnelli (Archive) | December 21st 2018 4:18 PMIn a tweet earlier this month, Minnesota State University Professor Eric Sprankle criticized the biblical account of the Annunciation saying that Mary did not give her consent. When the verses containing her fiat were pointed out to him, he walked it back saying that because of the power chasm existing…
READ FULL BLOG POSTThe Trojan Horse of Christmas
Santa's message to children is that Christmas is about gifts
By Rob Agnelli (Archive) | December 17th 2018 5:03 PMA recent poll revealed that almost one-third of Americans and Brits are in favor of “rebranding” Santa Claus. Santa 2.0 might wear sneakers instead of his trademark boots or he might become she or it, with 27% of respondents favoring either gender neutralizing him or making him a woman. Christian…
READ FULL BLOG POSTA Dogma for Today
The Immaculate Conception tells of both our littleness and God’s immensity
By Rob Agnelli (Archive) | December 10th 2018 4:32 PMIn The World’s First Love, Fulton Sheen draws attention to the timing of the definition of the Immaculate Conception. The first televangelist sees in Pope Pius IX’s declaration a certain prophetic character that stood in stark contrast to the spirit of the times. Fueled by Rousseau, Darwin, Marx, and Mill, the…
READ FULL BLOG POST