The Narthex
Pluriform Blasphemy
Blasphemy in heart and in deed
By James Hanink | July 26th 2023 11:31 AMWe’re used to “in your face” demonstrations, and so are Swedes. But now Sweden is dealing with something more, the public burning of the Quran. Iran’s Ayatollah Ali Khamenei is furious: “The insult to the Holy Quran in Sweden is a bitter, conspiratorial, dangerous event. It is the opinion of…
READ FULL BLOG POSTWhy I Write
Illuminating crises is what Catholic intellectuals ought to be doing
By John M. Grondelski | July 18th 2023 12:56 AMThere's a trope out there that orthodox Catholics write out of anger. That's unfair. I offer a short apologia for what usually motivates me to write. Take a piece I just published, on the murder of a 20-something Kentucky school teacher in Washington. The killing took place in broad daylight…
READ FULL BLOG POSTGod's 'Right to Privacy'
Christianity does not admit of zones of life shielded from the Divine gaze and judgment
By John M. Grondelski | June 27th 2023 9:36 PMIn the wake of the first anniversary of the Dobbs decision overturning Roe v. Wade, partisans of abortion-on-demand continue to assert their “right to privacy” and trot out numerous other bogeymen of what an “out-of-control Supreme Court” might yet do to “human rights.” In light of this obsession with protecting…
READ FULL BLOG POSTWhat the COVID Era Did
Ordinary people were no longer to be trusted to manage their own lives
By David Daintree | June 26th 2023 12:35 PMEvery nation cherishes an image of itself. We are often told that Australia’s was formed on the beaches of Gallipoli, but it’s older and more complex than that. Long before the Australian union, the people of the Australian colonies developed self-images of their own, in great variety. Few directly referred…
READ FULL BLOG POSTIs There a Moral Limit to Taxes?
While the state has a claim to taxes, that claim is not unlimited
By John M. Grondelski | May 30th 2023 2:56 PMOn Thursday, May 25, the U.S. Supreme Court handed down an important decision in the case of Tyler v. Hennepin County, Minnesota et al. Bottom line up front: a unanimous Supreme Court swatted down Hennepin County’s property tax collecting policy. I’m commenting on it because there are aspects of the…
READ FULL BLOG POSTVandals and the Church's Material Culture
Catholics once upon a time recognized the need to devote the best to God
By John M. Grondelski | May 22nd 2023 11:57 AMAs undergraduates at St. Mary’s College in Orchard Lake, Michigan, we were required as part of our core curriculum to take a course in art and/or music, and “Introduction to Humanities” fulfilled the requirement. I’ll admit that, as a 19-year-old, I wasn’t excited about the class and it didn’t help…
READ FULL BLOG POSTMotherhood and Relationality
Modern reproductive technologies have broken maternity into shards: genetic, gestational, social
By John M. Grondelski | May 16th 2023 11:53 AMWith Mother’s Day in the rear view mirror and fresh events crowding the daily “news” cycle, the controversy some retailers generated this year by offering women an “opt out” of Mother’s Day mailings and specials will likely soon be forgotten -- until it returns next year. I’ve tried to showcase…
READ FULL BLOG POSTThe Eroding Right to Self-Defense
Subways do not exist to be substitute institutions for those who need institutionalization
By John M. Grondelski | May 8th 2023 2:50 PMAs a moral theologian, I am interested in just war theory. Just war theory, which governs whether a country can go to war (jus ad bellum) and what it can do in war (jus in bello), is essentially a nation’s right to self-defense. That’s why I reject the arguments that…
READ FULL BLOG POSTA Heart of Mercy
Sr. Rosemary Connolly and the residents, staff, volunteers, and benefactors of Chicago’s Misericordia
By James Thunder | May 1st 2023 2:01 PMOn Sunday, May 21, the University of Notre Dame will award its highest honor, the Laetare Medal, to Sister Rosemary Connolly, RSM (Religious Sister of Mercy), age 92. When the announcement was made on Laetare Sunday, it was accompanied by a video (linked at the bottom of this post). Previous…
READ FULL BLOG POSTNo Great Expectations
Are bleeding wounds, not paying subway fares, and getting stoned before breakfast now normal?
By John M. Grondelski | April 13th 2023 12:10 PMThe Tuesday after Easter, preparing to exit the Washington Metro at my usual stop, I waited for the car doors to open. My eye caught something red on the edge of the door, which extended downwards, even to a blotch on the floor. I’m not a biologist, but I think…
READ FULL BLOG POSTCancelled, Again
We must go bravely to the barricades in defense of our beliefs
By David Daintree | April 3rd 2023 12:28 PMThe Dawson Centre’s call for Colloquium papers includes the following statement: “School children are taught to believe that girls can be boys, that boys can be girls, and that grown-ups should be punished for denying it.” Someone subsequently asked me for evidence that any “grown-up” is ever actually penalized for…
READ FULL BLOG POSTAgainst 'Detransitioning'
Use of a made-up non-word leads to tacit acceptance of the ideology that spawned it
By Jason Morgan | March 27th 2023 2:44 PMAn 18-year-old woman named Layla Jane was in the news recently with a heartbreaking story. Ms. Jane is suing Kaiser Permanente and another medical institution for performing a double mastectomy on her at the age of 13. (Her story has been covered by several national news organizations.) There was nothing…
READ FULL BLOG POSTAccompaniment and Discernment
Certain words, including some suspiciously 'churchy' ones, are enlisted in all manner of nonsense
By James Hanink | March 24th 2023 11:12 AMWords mean something. Sadly, their overuse leaves them captive to clichés. Thus captive, they can be enlisted in all manner of nonsense. Two examples come to mind: accompaniment and discernment. Note that both of them have become suspiciously “churchy.” Let’s start with accompaniment. Rightly used, it means “being with” another…
READ FULL BLOG POSTRealism on Ukraine War
The Biden Administration continues to fan the flames
By Barbara Rose | March 2nd 2023 7:04 PMU.S. conservatives are now able to openly voice criticism of Washington's continued pro-war stance in Ukraine -- able to openly voice meaning they can do so without being accused of being pro-Putin. The Overton window on discussing the Ukraine war has moved, making room for intelligent discussion and views that…
READ FULL BLOG POSTLent and Guilt
Guilt is the recognition that we have responsibilities and that other people matter
By David Daintree | February 15th 2023 3:28 PMI have a confession to make. For me and for many feeble Catholics like myself Lent nowadays is marked by little more than a cardboard money box on the kitchen windowsill and perhaps an intention to drink a little less wine and give up something nice like chocolate for six…
READ FULL BLOG POST