The Narthex
Signs of the Times
Popular yard signs that list slogans do raise some meaty questions
By James Hanink | February 1st 2021 8:09 PMVatican Council II counsels us to search out “the signs of the times.” The Latin, “signa perscrutandi” suggests the keen scrutiny this involves. One sign of our calamitous times is the invasion of the slogans of the day. What’s the difference between a sign and a slogan? A sign points,…
READ FULL BLOG POSTOn Patriotism
No national cultures are sacred except insofar as they reflect the Creator
By James Hanink | January 19th 2021 1:22 PMCharlie Camosy, a stalwart of the American Solidarity Party, argues that we should condemn the Capitol violence of “1-6” without using words like "sacred" and "temple" and "desecration." In his view, they are “not appropriate words for a place which (while very significant) is not sacred, not a temple, and…
READ FULL BLOG POSTFrom Comedy to Cosmos
Did you know G.K. Chesterton wrote the entry for 'Humor' in the 1928 Encyclopedia Britannica?
By James Hanink | January 4th 2021 5:00 PMGroucho Marx famously commented, “I wouldn’t join any club that would let me in.” I share this sentiment. But then there’s Miss Elayne’s “Simply for Laughs” online group. Count me in! The talent is top-notch. Here’s Miss Sheila’s latest: Seems there are a couple of factory workers. One tells the…
READ FULL BLOG POSTOn Quirks and Luck
Chance is built into the very structure of nature
By James Hanink | October 13th 2020 7:05 PMFrank Sinatra encouraged “Luck” to “be a lady tonight.” The lady in question had not always been so. Even perfect “strangers in the night,” wondering as they do “what were the chances” of “sharing love,” might well fare better. Johnny Mathis, he of the honeyed throat, was more upbeat. “Guess…
READ FULL BLOG POSTA Damned Argument
On appealing to 'historical necessity' in order to justify moral paralysis
By James Hanink | September 28th 2020 8:56 PMReflecting on the West’s strategy of nuclear deterrence, Winston Churchill expressed the hope that “safety will be the sturdy child of terror, and survival the twin brother of annihilation.” Can such a hope be reasonable? Some argue that however odious it is, nuclear deterrence, in light of world realities, is…
READ FULL BLOG POSTThe Soul of the Nation
Do Americans' day-to-day actions speak of unity?
By James Hanink | August 31st 2020 8:10 PMAre we about to vote for the soul of the nation? Well, maybe. The political figures who say so are keener than ever to get out the vote, as are the “thought leaders” now popping up everywhere. The first order of business for those who insist that political figures really…
READ FULL BLOG POSTVoting for Lesser Evil?
The American Solidarity Party is pro-life for the whole of life
By James Hanink | August 18th 2020 2:33 PMFor many years, when urged to vote for a US president, I’d push back hard. My favorite riposte? “Don’t vote; it just encourages them.” Still, there’s a season for (almost) everything. And who says that a bloke can’t change after he turns 39? Not I, and here’s why. Note: As…
READ FULL BLOG POSTMischief of Memes
Today’s popular public discourse is worrisome
By James Hanink | July 6th 2020 8:37 PMThe gravestone of former New York Times editor A. M. Rosenthal reads, “He kept the paper straight.” Last month, A. G. Sulzberger, publisher of The New York Times, disavowed “hiding behind” old standards. Sulzberger went on to say, “We’re not retreating from the principles of independence and objectivity. We don’t…
READ FULL BLOG POSTClear Thinking
Modern science stems from Aristotelian methodology
By David Daintree | May 26th 2020 3:46 PMEverybody has heard of Socrates, the Greek philosopher who was put to death by his own people in 399 BC. The charge against him was that he had “corrupted the youth,” but in reality it was his profound intellectual humility that killed him. He was as honest a man as…
READ FULL BLOG POSTIronies of Intelligence
It is the soul, through the intellect, that thinks
By James Hanink | May 26th 2020 3:22 PMThe New York Times vacillates in its effect on readers. Often enough it induces nausea. But sometimes it gives us food for thought. A recent obituary, “Joel Kupperman, Scarred by Success as a Precocious ‘Quiz Kid,’ Dies at 83” (May 15, page A24) is surely food for thought. So what’s…
READ FULL BLOG POSTMemory & Meaning
Consciousness subsists in the embodied person
By James Hanink | January 20th 2020 10:11 PMReady for a trip down memory lane? Even if you aren’t, a birthday can send you on your way! If it’s a septuagenarian birthday, count on it. Still, regardless of your generation, you can do some philosophical packing before you head out—or get pushed. For a start, it’s worth noting…
READ FULL BLOG POSTOn Measurement Muddles
There’s no scale to balance good & evil, or to take the measure of a man
By James Hanink | January 6th 2020 10:47 PMAh, the things we ask! When we’re running late, as often we are, we ask what time it is. When something goes missing, as it often does, we ask where it is. Or suppose we have a tough decision to make. Then we ask how to weigh the contending pros…
READ FULL BLOG POSTJust Because
Often answers are in terms of 'what causes what'
By James Hanink | December 9th 2019 9:14 PMEver run out of time to answer your children’s questions? (It’s not that we don’t have the answers, right?) Well, there’s always the handy reply “Just because!” But suppose it’s we who have the questions, and we don’t have the answers? What then? We could always ask someone, maybe a…
READ FULL BLOG POSTGod and Man at Play
Creation is ongoing, spontaneous, and forever surprising
By James Hanink | September 17th 2019 3:06 PMHugo Rahner, SJ, is the author of a classic work Man at Play. The central and staggering insight of Man at Play is that God is at play! How so? Proverbs 8:27-31 gives us a starting point. From the beginning, Rahner points out, Divine Wisdom (Hochmah) has been “playing before…
READ FULL BLOG POSTUnderstanding Humanism
Creation is its fundamental context
By James Hanink | August 20th 2019 2:21 PMThe devil is in the details -- and in definitions. For such details we might reflect on the new Vatican-Beijing accords, already in jeopardy, and the not-so-new nuclear weapons treaties now publicly flaunted. How about definitions? Let’s consider, as a trial run, humanism. As always, context counts. The French Revolution,…
READ FULL BLOG POST