The Narthex
What's Your Angle?
'Economism' and 'politicism' are merely intellectual viewpoints
By James Hanink | February 4th 2019 4:09 PMAsk me “what’s your angle?” around 7 am. If I can summon the strength, I’ll say that in five minutes or so, if I’m upright, I’ll be at a 90 degree angle from the floor. It might take a few tries, though. Graceful, I'm not. Intellectual angles matter even more…
READ FULL BLOG POSTTwo Cheers for Democracy
Politics needs philosophy
By James Hanink | December 12th 2018 7:01 PMLast week a young activist for whom I have sympathy wrote that he was hesitant to discuss democracy. Why so? Because he looks at democracy "differently." Democracy, he thinks, is only a tool to secure good leadership. But tools don’t always work. That’s why, he notes, once a party wins…
READ FULL BLOG POSTLocating God: a Logical Point
God isn’t a species within some genus
By James Hanink | November 15th 2018 4:32 PMRemember the drill? Which of these things does not belong? Example #1 (apple, banana, carrot). Easy! A carrot isn’t a fruit, so it doesn’t belong. Example # 2 (cat, dog, butterfly). Well, a butterfly isn’t a mammal, so it doesn’t belong. The logical point in each example is that the…
READ FULL BLOG POSTA Pitch for Practical Reason
Ensuring that good is done and evil is avoided
By James Hanink | October 26th 2018 3:13 PMLet’s list a few words: smart, clever, bright, ingenious. They’re all familiar. No one needs to make a pitch for aspiring to being smart, clever, bright, or ingenious. With “practical reason” we’re in a different territory. The term isn’t so familiar. It’s easy to confuse with “practicality.” And we can’t…
READ FULL BLOG POSTPity the Poor Pragmatist
Pragmatism eliminates both real freedom and real bravery
By James Hanink | October 19th 2018 8:52 PMAmerica, it’s said, is the land of the free and home of the brave. It’s also said, and might well be true, that America flies the flag of pragmatism. But if we are pragmatists, then the star spangled banner is at risk. So is our freedom, and our bravery is…
READ FULL BLOG POSTWill Beauty Save the World?
Art that presents truth as a living force is irrefutable
By James Hanink | October 15th 2018 8:16 PMA character in Dostoevsky’s The Idiot, tempted to despair, asks an intriguing question. Will beauty save the world? There are a couple of reasons to answer “not likely.” Here’s a first reason. Since there are sharply differing accounts of the nature of beauty, it probably isn’t any one thing. But…
READ FULL BLOG POSTWhat Studies Show -- and Don't
The presuppositions of studies merit scrutiny
By James Hanink | October 10th 2018 9:09 PMHummingbirds are wonderful creatures. Happily, their range is expanding. Studies show this expansion! Of course, we often read of studies that reach less welcome conclusions. Studies have shown that fish oil does little to lower cholesterol; they’ve shown that aspirin doesn’t reduce heart attacks. New studies cast doubt on the…
READ FULL BLOG POSTThought Blockers
Let us wriggle free of the 'conservative' and 'liberal' duopoly
By James Hanink | October 8th 2018 3:04 PMLet’s start with good blockers. Alpha-blockers and beta-blockers play a strategic role in reducing high blood pressure and even some cardiac problems. They’re health-defenders. Next up? Something seasonal: Fall’s the season for football blockers, especially welcome as goal-defenders. What about bad blockers? They’re a motley crew of offenders. Enter name-droppers…
READ FULL BLOG POSTHistory Puzzles & Providence
Nature is simply a starting point for grace
By James Hanink | October 5th 2018 5:18 PM“Don’t mess with Texas!” Right, probably a mistake. There’s no doubt, though, that it’s folly to cross Mother Nature. And Father Time? Why, he chronicles the history of our lives. Surely, then, Henry Ford’s famous “History is bunk!” is nonsense—on stilts. Isn’t it history that decides our worth and measures…
READ FULL BLOG POSTPhilosopher Responds to "Whatever!"
Nattering nominalists close the case on truth
By James Hanink | September 28th 2018 3:53 PMWhat is the aim of our clicking and reading? It is not to say, "Whatever!" The aim is thinking. And when we think, we form judgments. We think, for example, that G. K. Chesterton was a journalist, that gin merits tonic, that the Babylon Bee has great satire. When we think we…
READ FULL BLOG POST