Volume > Issue > A Humble Proposal

A Humble Proposal

GUEST COLUMN

By Sheldon Vanauken | January/February 1996
Sheldon Vanauken is a writer in Virginia whose books include A Severe Mercy, an award-winning bestseller.

Open Letter to the Holy Father:

Preface: We are all too aware of the tiresome clamour of feminist women and their male fellow travellers for priestesses in the Church. Clearly what they want is power and prominence in the Church and in the Mass. And no less clearly they do not, or will not, understand why the priest — in persona Christi — MUST be male, nor understand that the Church, the bride and spouse of Christ, is female.

And yet this must be allowed to them: The relationship of Christ to his bride and spouse — that the Church is female — is not made clear in the Mass. If I understand correctly, the priest in persona Christi consecrates the elements that become the Body and Blood, and then he, representing the female Church, partakes.

Proposal: I humbly propose that a girl or woman, distinctively gowned (perhaps all in white), representing Holy Church (conceivably in persona Maria), be standing or kneeling by the altar during the consecration, and that she be the first to communicate.

Enjoyed reading this?

READ MORE! REGISTER TODAY

SUBSCRIBE

You May Also Enjoy

The Priesthood Is Not Just a Job

The priest is a living reminder that it is Christ, made visible sacramentally in the "icon" of the priest, who calls the Church into being in the celebration of the Eucharist.

Briefly: February 1999

Reviews of The Lustre of Our Country: The American Experience of Religious Freedom... Henri Nouwen: A Restless Searching for God... Malcolm Muggeridge: A Biography... Toward a Theology of the Body...

Briefly: January-February 2011

Reviews of Pope Benedict XVI and the Sexual Abuse Crisis... Chimeras, Hybrids, and Interspecies Research...