Cardinal Scola Exchanges Views With a Muslim Leader
LAST THINGS
I tend to avoid interfaith dialogues. But I made an exception when I heard that Cardinal Scola was participating in what was billed as a “Distinguished Dialogue.” It would be held on January 17, at the John Paul II Cultural Center in Washington, D.C. Angelo Cardinal Scola, the Patriarch of Venice, would exchange views with Dr. Muzammil H. Siddiqi, the Director of the Islamic Society of Orange County, Calif., and the past President of the Islamic Society of America. (Venice, for some reason, has a patriarch rather than an archbishop.)
Their topic: “The Primordial Relationship between God and the Human Person in Catholicism and Islam.”
Was there not a certain inequality of rank? The Patriarch of Venice debating an Islamic leader from Orange County? It’s a pretty good rule of thumb that he who seeks a debate is the weaker party (“Can’t we talk?”). The other, in such cases, may have no good reason to accept (“It would be of no benefit to me”).
On the other hand, comparisons of weakness and strength are not easily made when contemporary Islam and Christianity are involved. Islam is a rising force in the world, while Christianity, in the West at least, seems to be in grave decline. Maybe the encounter would prove to be more evenly matched than the speakers’ titles suggested.
You May Also Enjoy
While mainstream journalists and academic talking heads exhibit a different kind of Islamophobia-- an inordinate fear of Islam-- they have no problems at all with shortchanging Christianity.
Belloc saw Islam as a Catholic heresy, and a heresy is an evil. Like Calvinistic Protestantism, it overemphasizes the transcendence of God and His "immutable decrees."
According to Pat Buchanan, Muslims hate us Westerners not for who we are but for what we do, e.g., abortion and sodomy.