Volume > Issue > Pretending to Be a Monk?

Pretending to Be a Monk?

GUEST COLUMN

By Aaron W. Godfrey | October 1994
Aaron W. Godfrey is Professor of Comparative Litera­ture at the State University of New York at Stony Brook.

It is almost beyond comprehension that the Spanish monks of Silos have hit the top of the charts with their album and compact disc, Chant. A genera­tion ago a few tapes would have been sold at the mon­astery shop and might be sent to some affiliated asso­ciations for a modest total of sales. The recording is good and the sound pleasant, but the purists at Solesmes and other experts would be quite critical of a certain lack of precision and an occasional drop in pitch. In short, the success of Chant is a phenomenon that few can explain except that it is peaceful, exotic, and in a language that few understand.

Another sign of the times is that among some New Age people, it is considered “cool” to visit monas­teries, whether they be Christian or Buddhist. The Cloister at Silos has been disrupted and inundated with tourists who wish to become part of “the scene.” Per­haps the fascination with monasticism is connected with the exotic quality of monks’ lives, the tranquility, the strange sounding liturgical language, and the pos­sibility of finding a way of feeling at one with the uni­verse. Dostoevsky was right when he asserted that most human beings want and need “miracle, mystery, and authority.” Monastic discipline represents author­ity, while the chant provides the mystery. But the miracle comes when people are changed.

I wonder if the New Age listeners are aware of the meaning of the chants and whether they would be so enthralled if they knew that the translation of the motet “Christus factus est” is “Christ became obedient for us even to death.”

Enjoyed reading this?

READ MORE! REGISTER TODAY

SUBSCRIBE

You May Also Enjoy

Effeminacy in the Service Of Capitalism

The intentionally effeminate metrosexual is another fruit of the postmodern sexual assault, specifically the assault on masculine integrity.

The Persistence of Islam

Review of Letters on the Sufi Path by Ibn Abbad of Ronda, Eight Lives by Rajmohan Gandhi, and Lost in the Crowd by Jalal Al-e Ahmad

Is a Return to Chivalry the Answer?

To begin with, male-friendly education must be restored, with an emphasis on competition over cooperation, and objectivity over feelings and sappy "story sharing."