Volume > Issue > Note List > Prostitutes in Portsmouth?

Prostitutes in Portsmouth?

Crispian Hollis, the Catholic Bishop of Portsmouth, England, wants to legalize brothels. But, says Bishop Hollis, “that’s not to say that I approve of prostitution in any way.” Really? Prostitution, Bishop Hollis says, is going to be with us “whatever we do and it has been from time immemorial. So I think that is something we have to be realistic about.” Rachel Frost of the International Union of Sex Workers praised Bishop Hollis: “The bishop should be commended for having the guts to come out and say that” (Reuters, Nov. 8, 2007).

Does Bishop Hollis have “guts”? No. He’s just blowing with the wind of the “Spirit of the Age.”

Bishop Hollis said of prostitution, “I think there’s a need to make sure it’s as well-regulated as possible for the health of the people involved…. [But] I do regard those involved in any way as involved in some form of immorality” (Catholic News Service, Nov. 8, 2007). Some form of immorality? Try lust, fornication, Onanism — sins against chastity. The Catechism says prostitution is “always gravely sinful” (#2355). Apparently, Bishop Hollis is more concerned about ensuring the temporal, physical health of grave sinners, and enabling their sin, than he is about securing their eternal, spiritual health by calling on them to repent and turn away from sin.

In his book The Roman Option (1997), William Oddie, an Englishman and a former Anglican vicar turned Catholic layman, said Bishop Hollis is sympathetic to the feminist agenda and hostile to opponents of priestesses.

Enjoyed reading this?

READ MORE! REGISTER TODAY

SUBSCRIBE

You May Also Enjoy

Reflections on Pope John Paul II's Legacy

There is now a general assumption that because the pope gets so much attention, he must have global tasks commensurate with worldly publicity.

Lost Shepherds, Vulnerable Sheep

Here, selected from a large collection, are snippets from recent homilies heard at Catholic Masses. To each I have given a response.

Dispatch from the Dead Letter Office

The McCarrick report is a historical accounting that doesn’t hold anyone accountable, and it will have no practical consequences.