The Sanctity of Life & the Right to Adequate Health Care
DETERIORATING HEALTH CARE IN AMERICA
Ed. Note: The following constitutes a somewhat abridged version of the U.S. Catholic Conference’s 1985 Labor Day message, written by John Cardinal O’Connor, Chairman of the USCC’s Committee on Social Development and World Peace.
The fact that at least 35 million Americans cannot afford adequate health care should be a deep concern to the Church and to our whole society. It is appropriate to reflect on what lack of sufficient health care means to people in this country. Affordable health care has been a major objective of labor unions and working people throughout the century. The enactment of the Medicare and Medicaid programs were major steps toward fulfillment of the goal of universal coverage. Decades of steady progress are now being eroded as discussion of health-care issues focuses almost exclusively on cost containment. In this statement I hope to look at some aspects of current conditions in health care from the point of view of Catholic social teaching.
Earlier gains in rates of health-insurance coverage are being eroded as unemployment and labor-force realignments leave a larger proportion of working people and their families with minimal or no protection.
By the latest official estimates, 35 million Americans have neither the financial resources nor public or private health insurance to pay for adequate health care. Half of those with incomes below the federal poverty standard have no insurance and are ineligible for Medicaid. Others with slightly higher incomes still cannot afford the cost of private health insurance and are ineligible for coverage under employer-sponsored plans.
The poor and uninsured in our country have often depended on care from publicly funded health services: public hospitals, community health centers, maternal and child health projects. Unfortunately, care from those sources has diminished as many public facilities have closed or cut back on hours or services. While some individual hospitals have increased aid to the poor, on the whole the private sector has not filled the gap. In fact, the combined effect of cost-containment efforts and increased competition has actually reduced care for the poor among private hospitals. In some states there appears to be a clear relationship between the growth of investor-owned health facilities and reduced access to care for the poor and uninsured.
You May Also Enjoy
Communism was founded on false anthropology, reminds John Paul, and that was its undoing. Consumerism can be undone the same way.
A poor woman once told me that the Church “belongs” to her kind of people, not to them, the rich, the quite comfortable — appearances notwithstanding.
It is a cruel irony that, in less than a century, Catholics have gone from being victimized as unwelcome immigrants to being widely perceived as racist victimizers.