The Narthex
New Oxford Blog

Pricey Farmers' Markets
What does food gentrification as seen at outdoor markets say about food and social justice?
By John M. Grondelski | September 25th 2025 1:05 PMRecently I wrote about what I call “food gentrification,” the displacement by grocers of staples for “foodie” treats, and its adverse impact on prices. My comments centered on a New York Times story lauding the “comeback” of bakeries offering niche (and premium-priced) novelties, one baker touting the fact that he…
READ FULL BLOG POSTFood Gentrification and Food Substitution
On living to eat rather than eating to live, and eating bugs for the sake of 'the planet'
By John M. Grondelski | September 24th 2025 12:21 PMI recently wrote about how what were once considered food waste products have increasingly hit the grocery market. My inspiration was last Sunday’s First Reading, in which the prophet Amos excoriated the commercial cheats of ancient Israel, specifically, his comment about selling “the refuse of the wheat” as food. But…
READ FULL BLOG POSTOn Saving God’s People
'Always be prepared to give a reason for the hope that is within you' (1 Peter 3:15)
By James Hanink | September 23rd 2025 12:25 PM“Please, I don’t want to listen to any arguments.” Heard it before? I have. But maybe it’s high time to “listen up” and hear some arguments. Especially sound arguments, that is, the ones that are valid in form and have only true premises. After all, the glory of such arguments…
READ FULL BLOG POSTProphet on the Profit Margin
The minor prophet Amos has much to say about maximizing profits
By John M. Grondelski | September 22nd 2025 9:34 PMLast Sunday’s First Reading was the prophet Amos decrying the religious hypocrisy and wage injustice rife in the Israel of his day. His indictment reads:
“When will the new moon be over," you ask, "that we may sell our grain, and the sabbath, that we may display the…
READ FULL BLOG POSTNot 'Our' Democracy
The majority does not treat the minority with magnanimity, but with contempt
By Jason Morgan | September 22nd 2025 12:07 PM“Our democracy” is in peril, we are told, endlessly, by pundits and politicians. A Supreme Court justice, talking heads, politicians, and academics have come out as worriers about the state of democratic politics. Even a former pope did so. In the United States, histrionics about “our democracy” have reached a pitch…
READ FULL BLOG POSTMetallic Sacrilege
Civic infrastructure and sacred symbols have become mere objects for plunder
By John M. Grondelski | September 18th 2025 11:12 AMA peculiar subset of modern moral corrosion is metal theft: the stealing of objects ranging from manhole covers to fire hydrants to be sold as scrap metal. Copper currently sells in the $4.60–$4.70 per pound range, making it a tempting target. What might look like petty crime is, in fact,…
READ FULL BLOG POSTThe Need to Stop Grasping
Christ shows man the path by not 'grasping' himself but taking the form of obedient servant
By John M. Grondelski | September 16th 2025 11:56 AMLast Sunday’s Second Reading -- for the Exaltation of the Cross, which preempted the 24th Sunday of Ordinary Time -- was St. Paul’s great hymn of Jesus’ self-emptying, his kenosis (Phil 2:6-11). One of the key texts in that hymn is verse 6, where Jesus is presented as treating divinity…
READ FULL BLOG POSTThe Assassination of Charlie Kirk
Woke culture demonizes anyone who dares challenge it, particularly a professed Christian
By Sabino Paciolla | September 15th 2025 11:50 AMThe assassination of Charlie Kirk on September 12 on a college campus in Utah, supposedly by a 22-year-old named Tyler Robinson who shot him in a single shot with a sniper rifle from approximately 200 meters, is not just the tragic end of a 31-year-old conservative activist, husband, and father…
READ FULL BLOG POSTRandom Ruminations #28
Back-to-School Guide for Parents... ERA is Dead... Tim Kaine on the Origins of Human Rights... more
By John M. Grondelski | September 12th 2025 6:47 AMBack-to-School Guide for Parents Family Policy Alliance (FPA) is the brainchild of the recently deceased James Dobson. It monitors legislative and regulatory developments with a direct impact on parental rights which, in many ways, is ground zero in the contemporary assault on the family. Make no mistake about it: When…
READ FULL BLOG POSTThe Right to Self-Defense in Canada
Legitimate self-defense can be not just a right but, indeed, a duty
By John M. Grondelski | September 11th 2025 11:22 AMCatholic moral theology, including just war theory, always included the concept of self-defense. A victim of aggression has the right to repel that aggression, whether it be a thief breaking into your home or a king marching with his 20,000 troops against your kingdom with 10,000. Nobody questioned that right.…
READ FULL BLOG POSTUnlocking the Locked-in Self
The 'dream argument' is a philosophical bust that leads to doubt of everything
By James Hanink | September 10th 2025 11:51 AMOnce upon a time, when I was but a tween, the Everly Brothers sang “Dream, Dream, Dream,” and crooned “Whenever I want you, all I have to do is…” Yes, that’s right, “Dream, Dream, Dream.” But there was a downside: “Only trouble is, gee whiz, I’m dreamin’ my life away.”…
READ FULL BLOG POSTWhat Is 'True Freedom'?
Many hold to a false notion of freedom, one that treats freedom as an end rather than a means
By John M. Grondelski | September 9th 2025 11:39 AMThe Sunday homily usually reflects on the readings for that day. Typically, that means the Gospel and maybe the First Reading, which often is linked to the Gospel. The Second Reading is usually odd man out since in their wisdom the designers of the new Lectionary decided on a continual…
READ FULL BLOG POSTCardinal Cupich on 'Traditionalism': An Opening to Dialogue
Do we have more active Mass participation these days? Most Catholics don't even go to Mass!
By John M. Grondelski | September 7th 2025 8:56 PMWriting in the Chicago Catholic (Sept. 3, linked below), Cardinal Blase Cupich tries to distinguish between “tradition” and “traditionalism,” invoking Ss. Vincent of Lérins and John Henry Newman on development of doctrine to make his case for Vatican II’s reform of the liturgy. He’s concerned that “traditionalism” is obscuring the Council’s…
READ FULL BLOG POSTIntersections Should Not Be Rainbows
Black-and-white clarity -- not culture war graffiti -- is what a crosswalk demands
By John M. Grondelski | September 4th 2025 11:35 AMA recent tempest in the social-media teapot concerns intersections. Not the kind that over-credentialed academics spin dissertations about in the name of “critical racial theory,” but the literal ones you walk across: crosswalks. Some jurisdictions decided to “celebrate Pride” by painting pedestrian crossings in rainbow colors. The Trump Transportation Department…
READ FULL BLOG POSTPope Leo Calls 'Lesser Evil' Catholics to Order
"They must have courage: the courage to say at times 'no, I can't!' when the truth is at stake"
By Sabino Paciolla | September 2nd 2025 1:39 PMThe timing couldn't have been more perfect. Pope Leo XIV took advantage of his August 28 audience with a delegation of politicians from the Diocese of Créteil, France, to reaffirm the principles of the Church's sound doctrine, unchanged over time. Pope Leo XIV's speech, extraordinarily beautiful, is disarmingly clear. He…
READ FULL BLOG POST