The Narthex
New Oxford Blog

Judgment Puzzles
Only God knows how any of us responds to His love
By James Hanink | November 1st 2018 3:39 PMPuzzles, especially real life puzzles, can drive us crazy. (When my dad was charged with doing this very thing, he’d reply “Sir/Madam, in your case it will be a short, quick trip.”) But puzzles can also lead to insight, and the harder the puzzle the more valuable the insight can…
READ FULL BLOG POSTBuying Happiness
The Church insists that human beings don’t reproduce but procreate
By Rob Agnelli (Archive) | October 31st 2018 3:39 PMA lesbian couple in Texas has become the first such couple to give birth to a baby that they both carried. Using a technique dubbed Reciprocal Effortless IVF, one of the women had several of her eggs fertilized while she acted as an incubator using a device called INVOCell. After…
READ FULL BLOG POSTA Pitch for Practical Reason
Ensuring that good is done and evil is avoided
By James Hanink | October 26th 2018 3:13 PMLet’s list a few words: smart, clever, bright, ingenious. They’re all familiar. No one needs to make a pitch for aspiring to being smart, clever, bright, or ingenious. With “practical reason” we’re in a different territory. The term isn’t so familiar. It’s easy to confuse with “practicality.” And we can’t…
READ FULL BLOG POSTImmigration and the Common Good
Thomas Aquinas gives an example of a just immigration policy
By Rob Agnelli (Archive) | October 25th 2018 3:12 PMAs reported in a number of news sources, there are now two separate “migrant caravans” heading towards the US-Mexico border, totaling about 10,000 migrants from Central American countries. Their crawl to the border is like a slow fuse sure to reignite the contentious debate over immigration. Protecting migrants is part…
READ FULL BLOG POSTMargaret Sanger Versus Gandhi
He foresaw frightful results from widespread use of birth control
By Richard DellOrfano | October 23rd 2018 4:56 PMMargaret Sanger, founder of Planned Parenthood, met with Mahatma Gandhi to gain his support for her promotion of birth control devices versus using self-control of sexual desire. She was sorely disappointed, as he predicted rampant licentiousness would result from widespread use of such devices. In 1934, an Indian…
READ FULL BLOG POSTPity the Poor Pragmatist
Pragmatism eliminates both real freedom and real bravery
By James Hanink | October 19th 2018 8:52 PMAmerica, it’s said, is the land of the free and home of the brave. It’s also said, and might well be true, that America flies the flag of pragmatism. But if we are pragmatists, then the star spangled banner is at risk. So is our freedom, and our bravery is…
READ FULL BLOG POSTPostcards for Africa
Attacking a sound-bite straw man only masks the real evil
By Rob Agnelli (Archive) | October 19th 2018 6:35 PMIn a presentation at the Gates Foundation's “Goalkeepers” last month, French President Emmanuel Macron made comments that appeared to be critical of large families: “One of the critical issues of African demography is that this is not chosen fertility... I always say: ‘Present me the woman who decided, being perfectly…
READ FULL BLOG POSTThere's Always Hope, if...
We can get our heads on straight
By James Hanink | October 18th 2018 4:03 PMThe headline caught my eye: “Banksy shreds a painting, and its value likely rises.” Even if you sampled the media fanfare, some background helps. Banksy is an unnamed but not unnoticed U.K. street artist. The painting, Girl with Balloon, first appeared in 2002 as a stencil on a London building.…
READ FULL BLOG POSTWhen #MeToo Comes for Your Kids
False accusations do long-lasting damage
By Pieter Vree | October 17th 2018 3:58 PMIn the wake of Christine Blasey Ford’s testimony during Brett Kavanaugh’s Senate confirmation hearings, her supporters exhorted us to “Believe Women.” That phrase became a rallying cry against sexual assault generally and Kavanaugh specifically. What does it mean to “Believe Women”? In its most basic sense, it means that we…
READ FULL BLOG POSTResponsible Parenthood
The Church was out-hustled by Margaret Sanger and her progeny
By Rob Agnelli (Archive) | October 16th 2018 4:29 PMWhen Margaret Sanger attempted to attack the Church’s opposition to contraception, she did so mainly through anecdotal evidence of the thousands of mothers suffering under the burden of too many children. She even went so far as to collect the stories of these women and bind them in a book…
READ FULL BLOG POSTDemons of the Privy
San Francisco has been dubbed the "Poop Capital of America"
By Richard DellOrfano | October 16th 2018 3:43 PMSan Francisco was recently dubbed the "Poop Capital of America" due to the high number of poop complaints reported in 2017. Local channel KRON reports that while dogs play a part, at issue is the number of homeless people defecating in streets and parks. Could "privy demons" be a reason why down-and-outers…
READ FULL BLOG POSTWill Beauty Save the World?
Art that presents truth as a living force is irrefutable
By James Hanink | October 15th 2018 8:16 PMA character in Dostoevsky’s The Idiot, tempted to despair, asks an intriguing question. Will beauty save the world? There are a couple of reasons to answer “not likely.” Here’s a first reason. Since there are sharply differing accounts of the nature of beauty, it probably isn’t any one thing. But…
READ FULL BLOG POSTPlease, No More Documents from Rome!
Church teaching goes from fresh and radical to utterly boring
By Barbara Rose | October 15th 2018 7:58 PMDoes the Synod of Bishops on Young People, running this month in Rome, strike anyone else as same-old same-old? The Church continues to come across as bureaucratic and uninspiring. Aside from some free trips to Rome for some motivated young people, it's hard to see how a train of meetings…
READ FULL BLOG POSTSchooling God
Nevermind the Creator's design for humankind
By Pieter Vree | October 15th 2018 6:27 PMStudent protests have become routine, such that nobody takes them seriously anymore. So now, the adults are getting involved — as they did with last April’s walkouts for gun control — approving and supporting their charges’ acts of “defiance” — which really don’t defy anything if everybody is on board…
READ FULL BLOG POSTThe Next Reformation?
Healthy clericalism recognizes the dignity of the sacerdotal office
By Rob Agnelli (Archive) | October 12th 2018 6:39 PMHistorical caricatures to the contrary, Martin Luther did not, at least initially, intend for the Protestant Revolution to happen. Even a cursory glance at his 95 Theses shows them to be far from revolutionary (assuming papal authority, validity of indulgences, etc.) and more like propositions for debate. The debate however…
READ FULL BLOG POST