Topics

From the NOR Dossiers

Latin Mass

Does Good Liturgy Beget Moral Virtue?

A BOOK CRITIC’S IMPRESSIONS OF A LIVING CLASSIC

Kenneth Colston

June 2023

Good liturgy involves good taste, and, as Burke said, taste depends on rational judgment, emotional maturity, and education — that is to say, the virtues.

VIEW ARTICLE
Liturgical Unity & the Crisis of Incongruity

OUT WITH THE OLD?

Paul Malocha

June 2023

Contrary to Francis’s vision, cutting off the old liturgy does not promote unity in the Church. Vatican II did not envision excising the old branch from the tree.

VIEW ARTICLE
Dystopia 101

A POST-'TRADITIONIS CUSTODES' SHORT STORY

John Cussen

May 2023

An example of a powerful ruler who should be like a caring elder but seems more bent on crushing dissent comes from an unexpected source.

VIEW ARTICLE
An Afflicter of the Comfortable & a Comforter of the Afflicted

PETER CAROTA’S RADICAL WITNESS

Alvaro Delgado

March 2023

Father Peter left a profound and enduring legacy as a pastor who knew the “smell of the sheep,” working with zeal and love on behalf of the poor.

VIEW ARTICLE
Tale of a Troubled Transition

Mary Brittnacher

November 2022

The protagonist of Mitre & Crook, Bishop Edmund Forester, determines to take a stand and do what he can to reverse the changes in the Church.

VIEW ARTICLE
Dying on the Wrong Hill

Thomas Storck

May 2022

The totality of the atmosphere of the liturgy chiefly determines whether or not it will lift believers toward the mysteries of God and eternal life.

VIEW ARTICLE
Traditionis Custodes: Taking a Bulldozer to an Anthill

TRADITIONALISTS AND POPE FRANCIS

Pieter Vree

October 2021

There are no protagonists in the latest liturgical drama, only antagonists. Nobody comes out clean, neither traditionalists nor Pope Francis.

VIEW ARTICLE
Making Sense of Our Liturgical Morass

Thomas Storck

December 2019

We need a clearer understanding of the Church’s relationship with her past and her tradition that will help guide us along the uncharted road ahead.

VIEW ARTICLE
O Death, Where Is Thy…Tickle?

THE OLD REQUIEM MASS MADE US PONDER THE LAST THINGS

John A. Perricone

December 2019

Everything in the old Requiem Mass forced us to consider death and God’s judgment, Christ’s mercy and our complacency.

VIEW ARTICLE
A First Step in the Recovery of a Catholic Vision of Reality

Thomas Storck

April 2018

The old Mass cannot be revived successfully in isolation or simply as a juridical mandate or even a catechetical tool.

VIEW ARTICLE
What If Pope Francis Were to Rescind Summorum Pontificum?

UPON THE DEATH OF BENEDICT XVI

W. Patrick Cunningham

March 2018

What options does a parish that currently offers celebrations of the Mass in the extraordinary form have if it finds itself unable to continue doing so?

VIEW ARTICLE
The Latin Mass After a Year's Attendance

WHAT I'VE LEARNED

Richard Upsher Smith Jr.

December 2016

The extraordinary form has a depth of imagery that the post-Vatican II revisers of the Mass simply eschewed, especially as regards the eucharistic sacrifice.

VIEW ARTICLE
A Dialogue of Forms

MUTUAL ENRICHMENT ?

W. Patrick Cunningham

July-August 2015

The Extraordinary Form and Ordinary Form sat down to discuss the first eight years of their formal co-existence, and invited me to record and moderate the conversation.

VIEW ARTICLE
Liturgy that Speaks to the Soul

Thomas Storck

June 2015

An emphasis on the liturgy as something that creates a sacred atmosphere does not mean that Kwasniewski downplays actual instruction in Catholic doctrine.

VIEW ARTICLE
Pope John XXIII through the Testimony of Silvio Cardinal Oddi

THE "JOHANNINE TURN" WAS CARRIED OUT BY OTHERS

Beniamino Di Martino (Translated by N. Michael Brennen)

October 2014

In light of the canonization of Pope Roncalli, the contrarian opinions expressed by Cardinal Oddi about the personality and tendencies of John XXIII are of interest.

VIEW ARTICLE
An All-New 'New Liturgical Movement'?
July-August 2011

The Pope's vision of a "hybrid" Roman rite may be an altogether new Mass, a third form that blends the best of both the old Latin and new forms.

VIEW ARTICLE
Universae Ecclesiae: A Blow Against Liturgical Absolutism
July-August 2011

A new Vatican document makes it clear that the old Latin and new vernacular Masses are both valid, a distinct refusal of liturgical absolutism.

VIEW ARTICLE
Out of the Liturgical Ghetto
July-August 2011

While we wait for a revival of the Traditional Latin Mass, it's interesting to examine survey results from Europe which reveal pent up demand for the old rite.

VIEW ARTICLE
From Guiding Lines to Institutional Reality
May 2011

In the case of both the Latin Mass and the ordi­nariates, Pope Benedict's response was to revolutionize a policy put in place by his predecessor.

VIEW ARTICLE
Liturgical Reform Did Not Start with Vatican II

Arthur C. Sippo

March 2011

The history of liturgical reform that led to the promulgation of the New Mass predated Vatican II by several decades.

VIEW ARTICLE
At Mass, Actions Speak Louder Than Words

WHY LITURGICAL LESSONS AREN'T BEING LEARNED

Michael A. Beauregard

January-February 2011

The rubrics, gestures, and symbols that are employed serve a fundamental and very useful purpose: they reveal and give witness to the faith we profess.

VIEW ARTICLE
A Defining Step Toward Authentic Liturgical Reform

THE THIRD TYPICAL EDITION OF THE ROMAN MISSAL

Rosemary Lunardini

November 2010

We ought to be thankful to Pope John Paul II, who set the stage for this momentous improvement of the Mass in the vernacular.

VIEW ARTICLE
Whither Goeth the Reform of the Reform?

JUMP-STARTING THE RESTORATION OF THE SACRED LITURGY

Ken Skuba

September 2010

What measures should be taken to fast-forward the reform of the reform; to stop the nonsense and increase the sense of the sacred at Mass?

VIEW ARTICLE
The Case Against Liturgical Antiquarianism

A COURSE DEFTLY CHARTED

Harold B. McKale

October 2009

We should expect liturgical rites wherein the priestly office is most clearly expressed as a living and continuous reality and not a static object in a museum display.

VIEW ARTICLE
An Interview With a Carmelite
July-August 2008

A Carmelite monastery in Wyoming is an exciting new element in the Church in America, and has proven to be fecund ground for vocations to the consecrated life.

VIEW ARTICLE
For Fear of the Jews
April 2008

Nobody would ever mistake the timid troupe that makes up the majority of Catholic bishops for radical imams who issue fatwas.

VIEW ARTICLE
Haste & Heroism
April 2008

In his revision of the Good Friday prayer for the Jews, Pope Benedict didn't compromise the call to "preach the gospel to every creature."

VIEW ARTICLE
Reinforcements Are on the Way
March 2008

The Vatican has decided to draft a new "instruction," necessitated by "confused reactions" to the Pope's universal indult.

VIEW ARTICLE
First Impressions Are Often Correct
March 2008

What was it like for a self-proclaimed "progressive" priest to celebrate his first-ever old Latin Mass? Was it onerous? Was it tedious?

VIEW ARTICLE
Understanding Divine Mercy Sunday

GUEST COLUMN

Robert R. Allard

March 2008

Don't let any pastor say no to celebrating Divine Mercy Sunday at every Mass that day, just like any other feast day.

VIEW ARTICLE
'Rebellion Against the Pope'
February 2008

A number of English bishops, including the Cardinal Archbishop of Westminster, is displeased with Summorum Pontificum.

VIEW ARTICLE
The Future Has Arrived
February 2008

The Tridentine Latin Mass is "catching on among young Catholics.... it is a hit with younger priests and their parishioners."

VIEW ARTICLE
Pope Benedict XVI Is Ambivalent About the Second Vatican Council
January 2008

The Pope says that he was "too timid" in the period immediately after Vatican II in challenging avant-garde theological positions.

VIEW ARTICLE
Msgr. Mannion Is Infatuated With the Modern World
January 2008

Even after Pope Benedict XVI's explicit universal indult for the Traditional Latin Mass, Our Sunday Visitor is still dismissive of the old rite.

VIEW ARTICLE
Do Not Make Me a Gentile
December 2007

The following blessing is recited every day by Jews: "Blessed are You, L-rd our G-d, King of the Universe, who did not make me a Gentile."

VIEW ARTICLE
The 'Signs of the Times' Have Passed Them By
November 2007

Traditional Catholics know which way the wind is blowing. How brutal for the Vatican II-niks! The "signs of the times" have passed them by.

VIEW ARTICLE
'Let Us All Practice Charity'
November 2007

Fr. Thomas Reese, S.J., of Georgetown University says, "Where there are groups that want [the Tridentine Mass], it's going to be a real pain in the neck."

VIEW ARTICLE
Ordinary & Extraordinary
November 2007

The Tridentine Latin Mass is extraordinary, from another source, from the outside world -- it takes one Heavenward.

VIEW ARTICLE
Where Has All the Latin Gone?

THE LANGUAGE THAT BUILT THE CHURCH

Mark Cole

November 2007

Latin was the true language of the Church and could always be relied upon to convey precise information because its meanings were fixed.

VIEW ARTICLE
Opportunity & Crisis

EDITORIAL

Pieter Vree

October 2007

VIEW ARTICLE
Does He Know the Mind of Satan?
October 2007

George Kendall says some Traditionalists become so obsessed with restoring the old Mass that it becomes a kind of idol.

VIEW ARTICLE
Divisive or Diversity?
October 2007

Fr. Richard McBrien has always claimed to be in favor of "diversity," but when it comes to the subject of the Old Mass, not so.

VIEW ARTICLE
'The Reform of the Reform' Is Going Nowhere -- At Least Not Yet
September 2007

Does the Pope's universal idult for the Traditional Latin Mass necessarily mean that Fr. Fessio's "reform of the reform" is dead?

VIEW ARTICLE
The New Mass Just Can't Be Fixed
July-August 2007

Wishy-washy Our Sunday Visitor is not known for taking strong stands; so, why is it so opposed to the Traditional Mass?

VIEW ARTICLE
The Anglican Use in the Latin Rite of the Roman Catholic Church

GUEST COLUMN

James S. Blankenship

July-August 2007

Many Anglo-Catholics who convert to the Roman Catholic Church are disappointed with what they find in the average Roman Catholic parish.

VIEW ARTICLE
The Gnostic Traditionalist

PUFFED UP

Thaddeus Kozinski

June 2007

The smoke of Satan is in both lungs of the post-conciliar Church, both the traditional lung and the non-traditional one, but it has a different form and different effects in each.

VIEW ARTICLE
From Protestantism to Catholicism, From the Novus Ordo Mass to the Tridentine Latin Mass

WAKING UP CATHOLIC

Michael Larson

May 2007

We step outside the world by way of something that stands apart from it. The Church ought to be that timeless and lucid entity by which we can see.

VIEW ARTICLE
Our Churches Will Be Empty -- Part II
December 2006

"It is our duty to be vigilant... Because, in the end, the people will assist at the Tridentine Mass and our churches will empty."

VIEW ARTICLE
Our Churches Will Be Empty
November 2006

A Vatican official makes a prediction: "In the end, the people will assist at the Tridentine Mass and our churches will empty."

VIEW ARTICLE
Will the Church Ever Be Loved & Trusted Again?

WHAT WE HAVE LOST - PART 1

Archie Salerno

June 2006

In the early part of the 20th century, the average Catholic was secure in his knowledge that he had arrived at the Truth and was striving to live it.

VIEW ARTICLE
A First Reckoning With the Latin Mass

SO MUCH LIFE PACKED WITH SO MUCH QUIET

Joseph O'Brien

October 2005

The Latin Mass is an immersion in mystery and an intricate recognition of my own subordination as simple creature before simple Creator.

VIEW ARTICLE
Refugees From the Vernacular Mass

LAST THINGS

Tom Bethell

September 2005

At our nearby Tridentine Mass, some men attend even without their wives. I tell you, this is a church that men don’t hate going to.

VIEW ARTICLE
Can the Pope Overrule A Vatican II Document?
May 2004

When it comes to liturgy, Gabe Huck would get the Most Despised Man in America Award.

VIEW ARTICLE
Why I Attend the Traditional Latin Mass

A HARVARD STUDENT SPEAKS OUT

Francis X. Altiere IV

June 2003

St. Thomas writes, "It is absurd, and a detestable shame, that we should suffer those traditions to be changed which we have received from the fathers of old."

VIEW ARTICLE
A Tale of Two Classics

GUEST COLUMN

Michael D. Rains

December 2001

During the 20th century two of the world’s largest multinationals dominated their competition with “classics” recognized even in the remote recesses of the earth.

VIEW ARTICLE
The Liturgy as Catechism

LAUDABLE LATIN -- OR UNSPECTACULAR VERNACULAR?

Jude A. Huntz

May 2000

Our major training in the Faith still comes principally from what we see and hear at church on Sunday.

VIEW ARTICLE
Conversational Latin for Today. Really!

BEYOND LITURGICAL LATIN

Thomas Storck

April 2000

Latin is an entirely suitable means for discussing all contemporary subjects, for bantering, arguing, playing games, and singing.

VIEW ARTICLE
The King James Bible & the Latin Mass

NO MORE MISSALETTES FOR CHRISTIANETTES!

Peter Kreeft

April 2000

We have dozens of versions of the Bible and numerous canons of the Mass, and people know and love them less than when there was only one version.

VIEW ARTICLE
The Archbishop Strikes Again

EDITORIAL

Dale Vree

July/August 1997

VIEW ARTICLE
Whither the Roman Rite?

Paul Malocha

Arguing that the Novus Ordo Missae is substantively different from the old Mass is not easy, even as it is plain that something is very different between the new rite and the old.

VIEW ARTICLE